Every time traffic congestion worsens or accidents spike, the response is predictable.
Increase the fine.
Add more penalties.
Announce stricter rules.
And for a short while, behaviour improves.
Then everything goes back to normal.
This cycle exposes an uncomfortable truth: traffic fines
in India punish violations, but rarely change behaviour.
The Rise of Heavier Penalties
India significantly increased traffic fines with amendments
to the Motor Vehicles Act.
The intention was clear:
- Deter
rule violations
- Reduce
accidents
- Improve
driving discipline
In the weeks following implementation, many cities reported
a temporary drop in violations. Helmets appeared. Seatbelts were fastened.
Signals were obeyed.
But the effect faded.
What the Data Suggests
- Traffic
departments across Indian cities have repeatedly reported that violation
numbers stabilise back to earlier levels within months of fine hikes.
- Repeat
offences remain common, indicating that penalties alone do not create
long-term compliance.
- Road
accident figures fluctuate but do not show sustained decline purely linked
to fine increases.
Fear works briefly. Habits last longer.
Why Fines Fail to Create Discipline
There are three core reasons.
1. Inconsistent Enforcement
Drivers quickly learn where rules are enforced and where
they are not. Behaviour changes accordingly.
2. Perceived Negotiability
On-ground enforcement still carries the perception of
negotiation, reducing the psychological impact of penalties.
3. Lack of Education
Fines explain what you did wrong, not why it
matters.
Without understanding consequences, compliance becomes
mechanical and temporary.
The Economic Disconnect
For many drivers, fines feel disconnected from income
realities.
For some, fines are unaffordable and create resentment.
For others, they are manageable and become a “cost of driving”.
In neither case does discipline automatically improve.
Punishment without proportional understanding leads to
resistance, not reform.
Cameras, E-Challans, and Automation
Technology has improved enforcement:
- Red-light
cameras
- Speed
detection systems
- Automated
e-challans
These reduce human bias and corruption. But even automated
penalties face limits when:
- Drivers
ignore challans
- Payment
enforcement is weak
- Repeated
violations carry no escalating consequences
Technology enforces rules. It does not teach respect.
What Actually Changes Behaviour
Global road safety research consistently shows that
sustainable discipline comes from a combination of:
- Consistent
enforcement
- Fair
penalties
- Road
design that encourages compliance
- Strong
driver education
Remove any one element, and the system weakens.
India often focuses on the easiest lever—fines—while
neglecting the harder ones.
The Role of Traffic Police
Traffic police operate under immense pressure:
- Staff
shortages
- Public
hostility
- Long
hours
- Political
expectations
Expecting behavioural transformation through policing alone
is unrealistic.
Discipline cannot be outsourced entirely to enforcement.
From Punishment to Participation
For traffic discipline to improve, citizens must shift from
fear-based compliance to shared responsibility.
Drivers should follow rules not because they fear fines—but
because they understand that order protects everyone.
Until then, fines will remain a temporary fix for a
permanent problem.
Final Thought
A disciplined society does not rely on punishment to
function.
It relies on understanding, design, and social agreement.
Until Indian traffic policy embraces this truth, fines will
continue to rise—and so will frustration.
No comments:
Post a Comment